A multi-criteria decision-making model for sustainable selection of coastal protection structures

Abstract

Although nature-based and hybrid (i.e., a combination of hard and nature-based) solutions provide welldocumented benefits to both the environment and people living nearby, they cannot be implemented in all coastal zones. Thus, the selection process of coastal protection structures (CPSs) requires an in-depth and comprehensible assessment with an effective and robust decision-support framework. Existing frameworks in the literature, however, do not focus on the selection of nature-based solutions and environmental and social factors were not considered thoroughly in these frameworks. In this respect, this research aims to develop a decisionsupport model that guides decision-makers in selecting the most appropriate and sustainable CPSs. The framework was designed in a way that includes a variety of environmental and social factors along with economic and technical aspects. Then, fuzzy AHP and TOPSIS analyses were conducted to determine the relative importance of the selection factors and to select the most appropriate CPS. Factors such as sediment dynamics, geotechnical issues, construction cost, transportation and navigation effects, and technological know-how were among the top-rated factors. TOPSIS analysis results revealed that mangrove forests and artificial reefs were the top two most sustainable CPSs. The proposed framework can minimize the social and environmental impacts of CPSs and expedite the green transition in the coastal environment.